Calvin Says Prof Must Choose Between School, Church


Professor Denise Isom loves her work at Calvin College and her Grand Rapids, Mich., church, Messiah Missionary Baptist.

The problem: Isom must choose one or the other.

The Calvin board last month refused to exempt Isom from a rule that requires professors to attend a congregation with ties to the Christian Reformed Church.

The issue sparked a student “prayer protest” and discussion about how the school’s church-membership policies may hurt diversity on campus. It also has drawn disdain from Isom’s pastor, Rev. Clifton Rhodes Jr.

“I’m not sure I understand the position of the school,” Rhodes said. “She’s not involved in some cult. We are a community of believers, and we, in my eyes, are quite compatible.

“I think it’s rather narrow of the college to say, ‘If you want to continue your worship, you’ll have to find different employment.’”

 Isom, an assistant professor of education since 2003, is black, and her research focuses on race and education. She told the Calvin board she finally found what she was looking for at the predominantly black Messiah Missionary Baptist Church.

“Though there are Christian Reformed churches and communities that are striving to reflect a multicultural vision in the church’s make-up and worship content, they’re not ‘there’ yet,” she wrote in a recent letter requesting the exemption.

Since the board’s Oct. 18 decision, college leaders and Isom have been exploring her options, said Provost Claudia Beversluis. Those include Isom’s departure from the private college or finding a partnership with a Christian Reformed church.

Isom, 42, told the board she visited churches of various denominations without finding a good fit. “I need a place of worship that is already consistent with my culture and able to grapple with issues of race in ways which make it a respite, a re-charging and growing place for me, as opposed to another location where I must ‘work’ and where I am ‘other,’” she wrote.

Beversluis said the issue is a difficult one that has prompted much discussion on how to retain the college’s Christian Reformed identity while becoming more diverse. “I wish there were a [Christian Reformed] congregation in Grand Rapids that was fully multicultural or even that there was one that was largely African American,” Beversluis said. (RNS)