Holy Catholic Church

Editorial
The church is holy because Christ stands in her midst.

In the church I attend we recite the Apostles’ Creed every Sunday. These days I find myself drawn to the statement “I believe in the holy catholic church.” That’s a good place to start thinking together about our identity as the Christian Reformed Church.

We should say this phrase with a taste of ashes on our tongues. The rise of denominations, like the CRC, stands as a monument to our failure to obey Jesus Christ and honor his prayer to the Father “that they many be one as we are one.”

How can we understand our identity as a denomination and still be faithful to Christ and to the apostolic faith expressed in the creed? 

One way is to keep in mind that our denominational identity and mission are always provisional and temporary. As with our own personal lives, what we are as a denomination is not what we ought to be. If we as a church really believe what we say in the creed, one of  the most important activities of the CRC lies in the Ecumenical Relations Committee.

On a practical level, each of us needs to learn to think of the divisions within the holy catholic church in a new way. It’s as though the light of Christ, that blazing, holy light of truth and love, has been refracted through the lens of denominations. As regretful as that is, we can at least recognize that the many colors reflected in the various denominations are each beautiful in themselves.

So in viewing other denominations, our first impulse should be to recognize the beauty of the one light of Christ refracted in each one: the evangelistic energy of the Baptists; the staggering beauty of Eastern Orthodox worship; the worldwide scope and influence of the Roman Catholics; the spiritual fervor of the Pentecostals. In all of them—not in any one of them—the full light of Christ can be seen. We can then value our own distinctive mission and doctrines, but only as a beautiful color in the rainbow of the whole church of Christ.

It’s important to notice that we don’t just believe in the catholic church but in the holy catholic church. That doesn’t mean we believe in the church only when it is pure and united and faithful. The church is not holy by the measure of its own efforts. Let’s face it, most of the time the church is a mess; the bride of Christ stands with a torn dress, dirty feet, and dripping mascara from her tears.

The holiness of the church comes not from herself, but from her Lord, the bridegroom. The church is holy because Christ has identified with her, redeemed her, and stands in her midst. He is the magnificent and holy one who walks among the candlesticks in Revelation 1. 

Each week in our worship it's as though we come in with ragged clothes and dirty bare feet, and Christ invites us to try on the wedding dress and look in the mirror. Can it be true? We are the bride of Christ, the holy catholic church?

That’s our deepest identity, before any denominational label, before any particular doctrines, true as they may be. We are members of the one holy catholic church, the body and bride of Christ.

A practical place to deepen that awareness might be in our congregational prayers. What if we prayed not just for the persecuted and suffering churches, but for the megachurch to which some of your members moved, the liberal mainline church downtown, and the Roman Catholic parish down the street? Doing so says that for all our problems, we are really the one holy catholic church.

About the Author

Len Vander Zee is a retired CRC pastor now serving as interim minister of preaching at Church of the Servant CRC in Grand Rapids, Mich.

See comments (4)

Comments

Thanks for your article.  The church I go to also recites the Apostles’ Creed weekly.  I tend to think of that creed as a simple statement of what Christians believe.  Should someone ask, what it is that Christians believe, you could then recite the creed to give a minimal statement of what historic Christians believe.

Of course, there are a host of other things that Christians don’t agree on.  And some claiming to be Christians don’t even feel comfortable reciting that famous creed (such as Mormons and others) that is supposed to unite Christians.  Your take on the creed is interesting but confusing.  It’s hard to know where to stand on the idea of the “holy catholic church.”  I like your perspective, but it stands at such odds with some of the Christian pillars that are revered in our denomination.  One such pillar is John Calvin who turned his back on Michael Servetus when he was burned at the stake for holding to his Roman Catholic faith. Or just read some of our confessions (in the original form) and see what Calvinists thought of Roman Catholics and Baptists.  Or more recently there is the abandonment of the Christian Reformed Church from the RCA because of its liberalism.  And of course there’s the Protestant Reformed group who left us because of teachings over doctrine and that departure was anything but graceful and in good will.  Who do I want to stand next to me with an embracing arm around me, John or Leonard?  It’s interesting how the church can flip flop all over the place.  There isn’t much flip flopping, though, when it comes to abortion or euthanasia.  We’re not too fond of holding hands with those kind.

So Leonard, you walk a difficult road, or pathway, or high wire.  You’ll get criticized for nearly anything you say, or you will receive great praise.  I think you did a fine job in this article, but maybe I would have gone a bit further with the openness you express.  But I guess you have to stop somewhere.  We want our doctrine, but with blurry lines.  Thanks, again.

Great editorial.  I have had the privilege in my life to work with a great variety of Christians from outside the CRC on a wide variety of real world concerns.  Doing that changed me in two ways.  First I learned how much "others" contribute to the kingdom that CRCers can't or don't so well.  Second, I learned what specific strengths those from a CRC tradition can bring to further the kingdom that others can't or don't so well.  Put more concisely, I gained in appreciation for both them and us.

So these days, it's not them and us to me, but just us, which I describe as many Christians who are come from different "traditions," a word I tend to use instead of denominations because I think it better describes.

And frankly, I often find myself more worldview aligned with particular persons outside the CRC as with some inside.  Ditto as to people who call themselves "reformed" versus those who don't.  The labels on the denominational boxes are becoming more and more useless these days, a change that I see, overall, as more of a good thing than bad, even if it is probably some of each.

Beautifully said.  Thank you.

Steve

We believe in one Holy Catholic Church, so true. It's amazing when born again believing strangers meet how quickly they recognize their oneness in Jesus. The church is built on one foundation, who is Jesus Christ our Lord, and not on sinking sand. The firmer the foundation the straighter the walls and the better equipped its members are to build the church. Not all churches build with the same mortar mix and its buildings show it. Yes, Jesus loves his bride the church and that's why he tells us over and over to watch out, be careful, do not..... and keep your eyes on the prize. Too many today build their churches to fit the culture and Jesus becomes a pleading bystander.
X