Skip to main content

When you transplant a tree, you must make sure that you carry a big clump of dirt with the roots from the old location to the new one. The older the tree, the bigger the amount of dirt that has to go with the tree to the new place.

The same truth holds for immigrants. When they come from Holland to Canada or from Korea to the United States, they need some of the old soil around them, otherwise they wither and die. I’ve seen a few immigrants who tried to be “Canadian” two weeks after arriving at the Toronto airport. Soon, they were nobodies.

Immigration is a process. For healthy development, immigrants must retain some of the old ways while learning the new. Older people need more of the old soil than younger ones. And some trees are actually too old to be transplanted.

Christians who move from one country to another, experience a special comfort and a peculiar temptation when they form a congregation in their new country. There’s nothing more comforting for a Korean or Dutch Christian than to be able to hear the Word of God in his or her own language, to sing in the familiar tongues, and to exercise Christian fellowship in an atmosphere that is reminiscent of the good old days. For immigrants the church does not merely proclaim the only comfort; the church itself is the haven of comfort.

And here is that peculiar temptation: the church becomes a Dutch (Korean, German) home away from home. By one’s speech and surname one is recognized as a son or daughter who is “at home” in this church. The group does not deny that the gospel must be sung in many songs and that God calls his people from every nation, but “our church is for our people.”

This would be perfectly innocent if it concerned the formation and continuation of a social club. But ethnic exclusivism becomes sinful when it concerns the church of Jesus Christ. The members of this church acquire a warped sense of values. They are kept together by a hunger for Holland or a craving for Korea; they have no appetite for Pentecost.

This is a touchy subject. If two people look at old customs and manners, the one will say, “rich and beautiful,” and the other will cry, “sinful and idolatrous.”

There are towns in Michigan, Illinois, and Iowa where old pioneers are praised who, to their dying day, maintained that on Sunday only Dutch should be spoken. By contrast, there are cities in Canada where the changes to the new climate were so fast, that older trees have a hard time surviving.

However, we have no time to indulge, and we cannot afford the luxury of indulging in the big squabbles about little things. The only big question for those who (should) read The Banner is: How must we live as God’s people on the place and in the time God has appointed for us?

I am sorry if we hurt anyone by burning these wooden shoes on the cover. You may also shellac them or bring them to Heritage Hall. Certainly, you should never apologize for your birth or your brogue. Neither is it God’s law that you must hate your grandpa when you love the Lord. The point is that you and I, as members of the church of Jesus, must think deeply on God’s will for this hour.

The Changing Time

Although the leadership in the Christian Reformed Church still has a strong ethnic (Dutch) coloring, and although there are still many congregations where the old Dutch influence is powerfully present, it is no longer true that the Christian Reformed Church is an “ethnic” church.

Two factors are now contributing to the change. First, there is the influx of the non-Dutch. In the year 1979 no less than seven thousand members were received by transfer from other denominations and through evangelism. That’s quite a number. The only reason why the church did not grow proportionately is the sad exodus of another four thousand.

Most newcomers are scattered over hundreds of congregations. Each brings her or his own history and adds to the variety of the whole. The church will experience the most lasting changes from the additions of blocs of other ethnic groups, especially the Koreans and the Chinese. I am somewhat acquainted with our Korean members. They are very ambitious and zealous for the honor of God. Their youth are studious; there are many Ph.D. candidates among them. Quite a few have a considerable amount of worldly goods already. In these respects, they will fit well with the Christian Reformed old-timers. But we had better pray for each other that all of us may walk humbly with the Lord and seek his kingdom first.

Another factor, a negative one, that contributes to the change of the church is the virtual disappearance of Dutch theological influences. When I was a student at Calvin Theological Seminary in the ’50s, the best books on any subject were always the Dutch books. We who could read the Dutch were a mile ahead of the ordinary American boy. We were made to believe we would make better preachers and, certainly, better theologians because we could read Dutch. Later I went to Princeton Theological Seminary where similar beliefs were held with respect to the German language.

This attitude has been radically altered. Of course, there are Dutch classics, just as there are French and German theologians of lasting significance, but the prejudice toward the Dutch professors has disappeared. This change makes for a quick independence of the Canadian part of our church. In twenty-five years, Reformed theology and practice have changed so much in the Netherlands that Canadian Christian Reformed people don’t recognize the rock from “whence they were hewn.” Therefore they look for a more independent expression of Reformed faith and life on this continent. And, if they read Christian literature at all, they are sooner inclined to reach for the American evangelical author than for the latest book of the Dutch professor. To their own surprise, they have a closer affinity with the former than with the latter.

The Necessity of Change

The Dutch Americans have been much more American than Dutch for many years, but they did not know it. There are whole tribes in Michigan who call themselves “Hollanders” but they are American as hamburger and apple pie.

I must respectfully differ with the scholarly analysts among us who have defined the “minds” of the Christian Reformed Church according to models derived from Dutch history. I do not deny that there are streams of pietism, Kuyperianism, and doctrinalism that can be found here and in the old country, but the influence of American Presbyterianism and evangelicalism has been underestimated. Especially in the isolated pockets of the church, where people think their theology and culture are very “Dutch,” they are unlike anything the old country ever produced.

It is not good to be an ethnic church. All older churches in North America whose membership is ethnically determined are dead or dying or, at best, they are sterile. The growing evangelical churches have many bad features: they lack historical continuity with the apostolic tradition; they have no confessional concern; therefore they are able to express that other trait of the true church: all kinds of people find their oneness in Jesus Christ.

The Mennonite Brethren also formed an ethnic church. But it is neither dead nor sterile because it tackles its most basic challenge: “How to make the transition to a fellowship of churches that can communicate their faith and full acceptance to people of all ethnic backgrounds, while remaining a Mennonite fellowship…” (Harold Jantz in the Christian Leader, Aug. 12, 1980).

Fear Not!

Inevitably the church is changing. We must not only accept this fact, but we most work for the renewal of the church. And we can contribute to its upbuilding only if we are able to discern between the historical, accidental traits and the Reformed distinctiveness.

The Dutch accent has little or nothing to do with Reformed distinctiveness. We must not be afraid when we are losing it. Just as the Mennonites have forgotten that Menno Simons was Dutch, not German, so we tend to forget that Calvin was French.

The Reformed tradition has roots that run much deeper than Scholte and Van Raalte. Actually, its faith was not derived from Kuyper, Calvin, or Augustine. All these are links in the chain that God has forged. But those who wish to penetrate into the deep resources of our heritage must travel even further: to Paul and Matthew and to the tents of Abraham.

The road by which we have received our heritage is not unimportant. But it is more important to possess the goods that have come along this arduous way.

We Are Counting on You

The Banner is more than a magazine; it’s a ministry that impacts lives and connects us all. Your gift helps provide this important denominational gathering space for every person and family in the CRC.

Give Now

X