Skip to main content

In this sequel to The Surface of Water, readers are catapulted into the spiritual chaos and suffocating secrets surrounding the fictional Calvary Community Church in Chicago and its associated Living Waters Conference Center along Lake Michigan.

In the summer of 2007, 56-year-old Pastor Mathew Goodman, the popular senior leader of Calvary, is found in Lake Michigan more than a mile out from the safety ropes set up by Living Waters. Though still alive when discovered by fishermen, his life hangs in the balance as he receives the best medical care available.

As the church community grapples with their pastor’s situation, their questions abound: Will Matthew survive? Why did Matthew, who was physically fit, choose to swim out such a long distance if he knew he couldn’t get back to shore? Did he plan to end his life? And, if so, is Matthew truly a Jesus-follower or a counterfeit?

When Matthew’s assistant, Trish Card, disappears without a trace, the community’s questions intensify: Were Matthew and Trish having an affair? If Trish has nothing to hide, why isn’t she around to answer questions from the church’s leadership and the media?

When 30-year-old Jonathan Goodman hears about his dad’s near-drowning, he returns from his home in Kenya where he serves at an orphanage. Jonathan knows several things for certain: the one date he had with Trish Card had sent him reeling and afterward he dreamed of having a lifelong relationship with her; his unease when he left the Calvary community to move to Kenya had not lessened and going home was going to be challenging and emotionally draining; and though his childhood and teen memories held some hints of happiness, they were fragile in the wake of myriad disappointments with his parents and their faith community.

Chicago police officer Andres Huertas has seen his share of violence, both in his personal life and on the job. Growing up in Trentwood, a housing development in a poor neighborhood, Andres knows what it's like to be passed over and discriminated against. But knowing Trish Card since grade five and falling for her defined Andres’s preteen and adult years. When Trish calls him in a panic, then disappears soon afterward, Andres is determined to do what he can to find the woman he loves and bring her home.

Author Cynthia Beach’s suspenseful, compelling narrative weaves together the stories of Matthew, Trish, Jonathan, and Andres. Throughout the book, Calvary Community Church’s looming and ominous presence forms the background to a story of betrayal, clergy sexual misconduct, cover-ups, shaming and shunning, and congregants thrown into confusion and chaos.

Throughout, Beach masterfully explores themes of redemption, biblical truth-telling, and the mystery and wonder of God’s unconditional love, which meets the brokenhearted when they call to him for mercy. (Soul Seasons Publishing)

We Are Counting on You

The Banner is more than a magazine; it’s a ministry that impacts lives and connects us all. Your gift helps provide this important denominational gathering space for every person and family in the CRC.

Give Now

X