As I Was Saying is a forum for a variety of perspectives to foster faith-related conversations among our readers with the goal of mutual learning, even in disagreement. Apart from articles written by editorial staff, these perspectives do not necessarily reflect the views of The Banner.
Parenting is hard.
My wife and I have three kids. They’re 7, 5, and 3, and it seems like our entire life is one disaster after the next.
The other day there was the mealtime meltdown that resulted in a plate of food being thrown on the floor that gave the dog a bonus meal, which then led to an even bigger meltdown that coincided with a bathroom accident that created an impromptu load of laundry that then resulted in a parent meltdown that led to another kid meltdown, which then led to the whole thing ending in tears, apologies, and the question, When will this get easier?
And that was all before 8 a.m.
(Sigh)
One thing I’m learning as a parent, though, is the importance of responding rather than reacting.
Reactions are the natural, knee-jerk impulses we have toward things. Fight or flight. Scream or yell. Anger, sadness, fear, and frustration. All of which happen a lot in a young family.
What’s a lot harder, though, is responding. Response, unlike a reaction, is deliberate. It’s thought through, reasoned, and intentional. Responses are, at least to a degree, calm, assured, and competent, even if the feelings behind them aren’t. They’re a lot harder to come up with, but they’re also a lot better in the long run.
And that isn’t just true in parenting. It’s true in terms of how we as Christians engage our broader culture too.
Fortification, Domination, and Accommodation
Historically, Christians have reacted to the broader culture in three main ways. I like to call them fortification, domination, and accommodation, terms I first came across in The Acton Institute’s 2014 video series For the Life of the World: Letters to the Exiles.
Fortification is a bunker mentality. It’s the idea that the world is bad, the church is good, and Christians need to hide away and hunker down in the fortress of the church, so that the “big, bad world” outside can’t get us.
Often this view holds out hope for a return to “the good ol’ days” of some imagined Christian Golden Age. It’s not until that Golden Age returns (whatever that means and whatever it looks like for those who advocate for it) that Christians who take the fortification view will feel it’s safe to come out of hiding and reengage the world. Given that our culture has become increasingly post-Christian, though, it’s unlikely that fortification Christians will feel safe enough to do that any time soon. Instead, they’ll either stay safely hidden away or switch to another approach, often the domination one.
Domination is a culture war mentality. Like the fortification approach, proponents of the domination approach believe the world is bad and the church is good, but rather than hiding away in the fortress of the church, they choose to do battle. “We need to fight!” they say. “We need to take the culture by storm, take it back, and make anyone who isn’t a Christian think, believe, and act like us, so that they won’t be a threat to us anymore!”
The main strategy for this approach, at least at the moment, is politics. “If we can just get some good, faithful Christian leaders in office,” domination Christians say, “then we’ll be able to turn the tide, win the culture war, and recapture the culture for Christ.” As a result, domination Christians marshal huge amounts of time, energy, and money in pursuit of political power and influence at local, state, and national levels of government.
Accommodation is a compromise mentality. It’s the idea that maybe the world’s not great, but maybe it’s not so bad either. Maybe we don’t need to be so cautious as Christians. In fact, maybe we can even give in a little. Maybe there are some areas of our faith that we don’t need to take so seriously, that we don’t need to hold onto so tightly, and that we don’t even need to hold onto at all.
You can probably tell from the way I’m writing this that I think each of these approaches to the broader culture is flawed. While some of these strategies worked in the past (and some of them might still work in other cultural contexts) in the postmodern, post-Christian, secular West, I don’t think any of these strategies will work anymore. Instead, they’ve become precisely the sort of knee-jerk reactions we need to avoid.
A Better Response
We need a better approach, a more deliberate, calm, and reasoned strategy to reach our culture as Christians today. That’s because we need to respond to our culture rather than react to it, and I’m convinced that one of the best ways to do that is something Tim Keller and others have called “faithful presence.”
Faithful Presence
What is “faithful presence”?
The definition is right there in the name: “faithful presence” means living faithfully as Christian believers while still being present in the broader culture. Both sides of that definition—faithfulness on the one hand and presence on the other—are important. We have a tendency as Christians these days, especially when we feel fearful, nervous, or anxious (reactionary, to use the term we used before), to emphasize one over the other. Either we emphasize faithfulness at the expense of presence (which really just boils down to the fortification or domination approaches), or we emphasize presence at the expense of faithfulness (which boils down to the accommodation approach). But we need faithfulness and presence to engage our culture as Christians today.
Faithful
There are some Christians out there who argue that we should change, tweak, or downplay certain aspects of the gospel in order to make our faith more attractive or relevant for our culture. But I disagree. I don’t think altering the gospel is a viable option for Christians. Instead, we need to stay faithful to the gospel for at least three reasons:
First, we need to stay faithful to the gospel because it’s true. By definition, the gospel is the good news of the Christian faith. And if it’s really true, then we don’t need to tweak, change, or downplay it. We simply need to share it and spread it so that those who don’t yet know it can believe it too.
Second, contrary to what we’re often told, people actually find our faithfulness to the gospel attractive. As a friend of mine once said, “People find it attractive when you know what you think.” And they do. Whether they agree with what you believe or not, they’ll at least respect the fact that you agree with what you believe. They’ll be intrigued too, because deep down they’ll wish they had that kind of certainty about something they believe too.
Third, our faithfulness as Christians keeps us rooted. In a culture where the sands are always shifting, the fenceposts are always moving, and the definitions of right and wrong are always changing, the gospel gives us a place to stand. Even if no one else knows what they believe, we do, and in an age when people are constantly anxious about all the options on the table (“Believe this! Believe that! Believe it all!”), the gospel provides Christians with a sense of relief and comfort.
For those reasons and more, our faithfulness as Christians—our commitment to the gospel and our unwavering trust in the good news of Jesus Christ—is a vital piece of how we need to engage our broader culture today.
Presence
That brings me to the second piece of “faithful presence,” which is, you guessed it, presence.
If we want to have an effect on people and, by extension, our broader culture, then we actually need to be part of that culture and present with the people who make it up. This, for instance, is why older methods of evangelism (“The Four Spiritual Laws,” “Evangelism Explosion,” and so on) don’t work as well anymore. They used to work. You used to be able to walk up to someone you didn’t know or knock on their door, explain the gospel, and convert them to Christianity. But it doesn’t work that way anymore. And a big reason why it doesn’t work that way anymore is because those evangelistic methods lack presence.
Put simply, people won’t listen to us talk about our faith as Christians without presence these days. They won’t listen to us talk about Jesus unless we form relationships with them. And they won’t listen to us share the gospel unless we demonstrate our love and care for them. And not just until they convert or do what we want them to (become a Christian). Instead, we need to be there for the long haul. We need to stick with them. We need to be faithfully present with them.
That's how we need to go about engaging our culture as Christians today. Rather than reacting to our culture with the fortification, domination, and accommodation approaches, we need to respond with faithfulness and presence instead, both halves of that together.
*Editor’s note: This article is adapted from Brandon’s new book, Streams in the Wilderness: Living as a Christian in a Postmodern, Post-Christian, Secular World, out now from Wipf &Stock Publishers.
About the Author
Brandon Haan serves as the senior pastor at Ivanrest Church in Grandville, Mich. He lives in Grandville with his wife, Sarah, and their three children, Levi, Titus, and Audrey.