Note: This online-only article is part of a series showcasing past Banner editors. You can read all the content celebrating The Banner’s 160th anniversary here.
Rev. John Suk was appointed as Banner editor by Synod 1993 with high praise. Normally, Christian Reformed synods would be presented with two candidates, but that year Suk was the only candidate, on the grounds that he had “significantly superior writing ability and editorial insight to warrant a single nomination.”
Suk left his mark on The Banner by fighting for its editorial freedom in 1998. Christian Reformed Home Missions and several CRC members had invested in a company called IRM, and when The Banner wanted to report on it, denominational leaders tried to block the reporting, citing legal issues. Synod 1998 decided in favor of The Banner’s editorial freedom to do such reporting, despite the wishes of denominational leaders.
Suk spent his final year as editor on the road in an RV to pursue “the spirit of the CRC.” He wrote his editorials from waypoints along the road.
By the end of Suk’s tenure, The Banner frequency was cut in half to biweekly, due to declining subscriptions and revenue.
When Suk retired in 2003, he told synod about some of his most memorable moments as editor. Most memorable, he said, was his visit to Rwanda, where he saw a mountain made of bones from 50,000 people who died during the genocide in that country. “Ever since Rwanda,” he said, “when I pray it is always with a spiritually difficult and often overwhelming sense of this world’s suffering and disappointment.”’
He said that during his time at The Banner he had changed his mind about many things, but “I’m not a cynic,” he said. “Mostly I’m full of thanks to the CRC for the privilege of serving in this way, and full of gratitude to God for the pleasure and excitement and joy I found in this work.”
But that joy did not last. On his blog he wrote of the 300 or so articles and editorials he wrote during his time at The Banner: “I now think that the vast majority of what I wrote is either misinformed or just plain wrong. … All of this was in service of an institution whose core raison d’etre I no longer share, whose core story I admire, but no longer believe to be God’s Word.”
In 2012, Suk resigned from the Christian Reformed Church and subsequently pastored a United Church of Canada congregation in Toronto. “I have long struggled with my doubt and uncertainty about Christian Reformed teachings. For many reasons, this struggle has become very intense over the last year, and especially the past few months. I have come to the conclusion that I can in good conscience no longer serve as a pastor in the CRC,” he wrote in an announcement.
He now describes himself as an agnostic. This year, he wrote, “What meaning there is, we have to make on our own, without divine intervention. Looking to the future, I have no comfort in life and in death. I sometimes feel like a wounded soldier dragging himself home after surviving a lost battle. God has disappeared. And yet, I am haunted.”
About the Author
Gayla Postma retired as news editor for The Banner in 2020.